Baseball Hall of Fame in 2027

Pettitte, K-Rod, and Jimmy Rollins

Who would I like to see make it into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2027? Here are the rules: All players who remained eligible from the 2026 Ballot and all players who retired following the 2021 season with ten-plus seasons in the major leagues and a score of 10 or more in the HOF Monitor were listed on the Baseball Reference page on November 16: some 44 players.

But the official ballot, mailed to more than 400 voting members of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America, included only 27 players: 14 new candidates and 13 holdovers. The HOF Monitor score cutoff was about 26, though two were on the ballot, Asrubal Cabrera (13) and Brett Garner (14), with lower scores. Ballots must be returned by December 31.

If I could vote, I’d continue to support these guys:

SP Andy Pettitte (9th year on the ballot, received 48.5% of the votes (75% is required), 128 on the HOF monitor)

RP  Francisco Rodríguez (5th year, 11.8%, 124) 

 SS Jimmy Rollins (6th year, 25.4%, 121)

I’ll add:

RF Bobby Abreu (8th, 30.8%, 95)

SS Chase Utley (4th, 59.1%, 94) – I think he gets in

2B Dustin Pedroia (3rd, 20.7%, 94) – even though he was a Red Sox player

Newbies

Of the newly eligible, I’d pick 

 P Jon Lester (98 HOFm) – “Five-time All-Star (2010-11, 2014, 2016, 2018)…Placed in Top 10 of his league’s Cy Young Award voting in four seasons (2010: 4th; 2014: 4th; 2016: 2nd; 2018: 9th)”  He was a member of the 2007 and 2013 Red Sox World Series title teams 9sigh) and the 2016 Cubs World Series title team. (YAY!)

C Buster Posey (79 HOFm) – “Batted better than .300 in six seasons (2010, 2012, 2014-15, 2017, 2021) en route to .302 lifetime mark, making him one of only seven catchers with at least 1,000 games played (at least half of which came at catcher) and a .300 batting lifetime average.” He has been the San Francisco Giants’ president of baseball operations since 30 September 2024.  

Here are the storylines that the New York Times foresees.

Contemporary Baseball Era

“Four managers and four executives comprise the Contemporary Baseball Era non-player ballot, which features candidates whose primary contribution to the game came since 1980.

“The results of the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee vote will be announced live on MLB Network at 8 p.m. ET on Sunday, Dec. 6.”

My problem is that I like them all. 

Sandy Alderson became the A’s general manager. He oversaw the building of a dynasty that would reach the World Series in three straight years from 1988-90, winning a championship in ’89. He later helped build the Mets into a contender, and in 2015, the Mets reached the World Series.

Dusty Baker managed the Giants (1993-2002), the Cubs (2003-2006), the Reds (2008-2015), the Nationals (2016-17), and the Astros (2020-2023). His teams almost always contended. He finally won that elusive World Series title with Houston in 2022. 

Bruce Bochy managed the Padres, Giants and Rangers over 28 seasons, leading his clubs to nine Postseason berths, six first-place finishes and four World Series titles. The 1996 National League Manager of the Year, Bochy finished in the top three of the MOY voting seven times. Bochy, who played nine seasons in the big leagues as a catcher, is one of only six managers in history with at least four World Series wins.

Cubbies drought was over

Joe Maddon managed Tampa Bay to the American League championship in his second year as manager. He guided the Rays back to the postseason three more times. In 2015, the Cubs signed Maddon, and he immediately shepherded the young club to a playoff appearance on the heels of a last-place finish in the NL Central the prior year. In 2016,  Maddon’s squad broke a 108-year championship drought by winning a thrilling seven-game Fall Classic against Cleveland. 

Lou Piniella managed the Yankees and Reds. But his most famous managerial tenure came with the Mariners from 1993-2002. He guided Seattle to its first playoff appearance in 1995, then led Seattle to postseason appearances again in 1997, 2000, and ’01. He was named AL Manager of the Year twice, in 1995 and 2001. Piniella has been on an Era Committee ballot three times before — including in 2018 and ’23, when he fell one vote shy of election.

Brian Sabean was named the Giants their general manager, which was the beginning of a 29-year tenure with San Francisco that has resulted in three World Series championships (2010, ’12 and ’14), four NL pennants (2002, ’10, ’12 and ’14), five NL West titles (1997, 2000, ’03, ’10 and ’12) and three other postseason berths via the Wild Card (2002, ’14 and ’16). Sabean was named the Baseball America Executive of the Year in 2003 and 2012.

TBS

Ted Turner, who passed away on May 6, was a legend in the fields of media and sports. He founded the Turner Broadcasting System (TBS) in 1976, and the Cable News Network (CNN) in 1980, revolutionizing cable television. He also owned the Braves from 1976-96, seeing his franchise become the “team of the ’90s” and bring Atlanta its first major sports championship with a World Series victory in 1995. 

Bill White, following his playing career, became a broadcaster for the Yankees, calling games with former Yankees shortstop Phil Rizzuto for 18 seasons. In 1989, White was named president of the NL, becoming the first Black league president of any major North American sports league. White served in that position until 1994, and during that span, he oversaw the expansion of the league by two teams, with the birth of the Rockies and Marlins in ’93.  White received the Hall of Fame’s Buck O’Neil Award for Lifetime Achievement in 2026.

I may have a slight bias toward the players I remember watching (Boche, White, and especially Baker and Pinella), but they are all worthy.